Wednesday, January 26, 2011

Drama, Drama, Drama


"It was one of those midsummer Sundays when everyone sits around saying, "I drank too much last night." You might have heard it whispered by the parishioners leaving church, heard it from the lips of the priest himself, struggling with his cassock in the vestiarium".

These are the first few lines of "The Swimmer" by John Cheever. When I read the first act of Henry V, this is what I thought of. It seems that Shakespeare is emphasizing the violent and bloodthirsty mindset permeating England at this time by highlighting even the priest's focus on going to war. He encourages Henry to "unwind [his] bloody flag!"And just as alcohol and indulgence infused this suburban society, violent dominance was on the minds of everyone within power. What kind of priest encourages bloodshed over such a selfish and frivolous concern? During the relatively peaceful Elizabethan era, Shakespeare's audience most likely enjoyed a dramatization of war, and so it's possible that this bellicose culture is a bit exaggerated.

I also find it interesting that Henry and his advisors are convinced that they're going to war in the name of God and have secured His support. Did Henry believe this to be true because he was convinced to go to war by priests?

Comments (3)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I don't have an answer for you but i have some thoughts. We talked about this in our group in class yesterday and we wondered if the priest told them to go to war so that they could get money from another government rather than the church. If so this makes one wonder how corrupt the church was "Go kill people so we don't have to give you money." Also have you seen the king Arther with Clive Owen and Kiera Knightly? If yes do you remember the kid they went to save? Well if yes and if no the kid believed that he was chosen be God and so it was the responsibility of everyone else to protect him. He had a sense of religious entitlement. Others in the movie did as well. They believed their cause was just because they believed God had chosen them to rule above others. So along these lines it seems like maybe Henry really did believe that it was God's will that he won the battle, he was chosen to be King and he was chosen to win the battle. This also seems reasonable considering the fact that he was waited on hand and foot from a very young age, the sense of entitlement is a sense of "I am me therefore I deserve this."
Beginning a blog post with an intriguing quotation is a good move. A nice example -- especially since I was hungry to see the connection between Cheever and Shakespeare. You used it to raise a clear and relevant issue.

I wonder if some of the material in our textbook regarding the political and religious environment of the day would be helpful here. The two were so intertwined, of course.
I think this is made even more interesting because almost everyone in the kingdom praises Henry for being such a noble king. And yet, does no one recognize that he is a little too quick to draw his sword?

At the same time, though, I was thinking about the war stories in the Book of Mormon. How many times do we see that the Nephites have miraculously survived a brutal battle against the Lamanites? I just kept going back to that. (:

Post a new comment

Comments by